Feta vs Store-Bought: Why Homemade Wins Every Time

Once you've tasted fresh, handmade feta, the plastic-wrapped supermarket version just doesn't compare. Here's what makes homemade feta so special — and why it's worth making yourself.

The Flavour Difference

Commercial feta is often made with shortcuts — pasteurised at high temperatures, pressed quickly, and stored in brine with preservatives. The result is a cheese that's salty, one-dimensional, and often rubbery.

Homemade feta is a completely different experience. When you make it with quality unhomogenised milk and proper cultures, you get layers of flavour — tangy, creamy, slightly nutty. The texture is softer, creamier, and crumbles beautifully.

You Control the Ingredients

When you make feta at home, you know exactly what goes in: milk, cultures, rennet, and salt. No preservatives, no stabilisers, no mystery ingredients. Just pure, honest cheese.

It's Surprisingly Easy

Feta is one of the most approachable cheeses for beginners. The process is straightforward — heat the milk, add cultures and rennet, cut the curds, drain, and brine. No special equipment needed beyond what you probably already have in your kitchen (plus a thermometer and some cheesecloth).

How to Use Your Homemade Feta

• Crumbled over a Greek salad with ripe tomatoes and good olive oil

• Baked in the oven with cherry tomatoes, herbs, and a drizzle of honey

• Stuffed into roasted capsicums or zucchini

• Simply on crusty bread with a glass of Barossa wine

Learn to Make Feta

Our Feta Cheesemaking Workshop takes you through the entire process from start to finish. You'll leave with your own block of fresh feta and the skills to make it whenever you like.

Explore Workshops